Questions? email us

If the Phase 1 Environmental Site Assessment is used for the purpose of measuring business risk 99% of the time, and the Phase 1 is used to qualify a buyer for the Innocent Landowner defense under CERCLA one percent of the time, then the ASTM standard should be changed to reflect its use.  

Many commercial real estate lenders, understanding this nuance, will have one scope of work for the loan underwriting process that for lack of a better word could be called a Business-Risk Phase 1 Environmental Site Assessment, while maintaining a separate scope of work for Pre-Foreclosure Phase 1 Environmental Site Assessments.   Often the Pre-Foreclosure Phase 1s are 100% compliant with the EPA’s All Appropriate Inquiry Rule in order to qualify for the Innocent Landowner defense under CERCLA.   I find this to be a fine approach, but for arguments sake I ask: is environmental liability CERCLA liability?   Or does environmental liability take another form: reduced real estate value in the market, state regulatory action that is non-CERCLA driven, or third party non-CERCLA lawsuit?

My point is that ASTM spends too much time on CERCLA and the Innocent Landowner defense.   How would the Phase 1 Environmental Site Assessment change if we spent less time worrying about CERCLA?   Maybe not much, but I think we would rethink a couple scope items.  For example, the Environmental Lien Search is a scope item that in my opinion does not yield enough value to justify the cost.

Happy Holidays,
Joe Derhake, PE

Be Sociable, Share!
Profile photo of Joe Derhake, PE
Education: MBA, University of Southern California BS, Civil Engineering, Michigan State University Registrations: Registered Professional Civil Engineer, California Registered Professional Civil Engineer, Arizona Registered Professional Civil Engineer, Tennessee EPA Accredited Asbestos Inspector, Management Planner Designer (not current) Affiliations: Member, Environmental Banker's Association Member, Mortgage Banker's Association Mr. Derhake serves as the President of Partner Engineering and Science, a national engineering and environmental consulting firm. He has over 10,000 real estate transactions throughout his career. His due diligence resume includes experience at all levels, including advising lenders and real estate investors through the following product types: Phase I Environmental Site Assessments, Phase II Subsurface Investigations, Phase III Site Characterizations, Remedial Cost Estimates, and Environmental Transaction Screens. Mr. Derhake has a significant portfolio of closed sites and speaks regularly at industry events and conferences.

Related Posts

Environmental Bankers Association San Francisco 2013 Recap

Partner Spring Webinars

1 Comment

  1. December 9, 2010, 9:23 am   / 

    […] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Partner Engineering, Partner Engineering. Partner Engineering said: […]

    [WORDPRESS HASHCASH] The comment’s server IP ( doesn’t match the comment’s URL host IP ( and so is spam.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.